The radiator and engine block of your vehicle develop dirt and rust over time. Of all the techniques, coolant flush or drain and fill services are often chosen to clean and replace old coolant to restore its performance.
But what’s the difference between the coolant flush vs drain and fill? A coolant flush is a maintenance procedure that thoroughly cleans and replaces the coolant in an engine’s cooling system. At the same time, the drain and fill remove the existing coolant, then pour new premixed coolant fluid.
However, there are more contrasts between these two services. Keep reading for a detailed comparison and learn which service is best for you.
Quick Comparison Table: Coolant Flush VS Drain and Fill
Before I walk you through a comprehensive comparison between these two processes, take a quick look at these brief contrasts:
| Characteristic | Coolant flush | Drain and Fill |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | To clean out the entire cooling system and remove rust, scale, and other debris | To remove the old coolant and replace it with new coolant |
| Chemical solution | Mostly contain acids and alkalis | No chemical solution is used |
| Effectiveness | More effective at removing rust, scale, and other debris | It is less effective compared to flush |
| Cost | More expensive | Less expensive |
| Time | Takes longer to complete | Takes less time to complete |
| When to do it | Recommended every 2-5 years | It can be done more often, like every 1 or 2 years |
| Vehicle Types | High-mileage vehicles | Low-mileage vehicles |
| Benefits | Removes rust, scale, and other debris from the entire cooling system, improves performance, and prevents overheating and corrosion | Removes old coolant and replaces it with new coolant, which can help to improve performance and prevent overheating |
What Is A Flush and Drain and Fill for Coolant?
A coolant flush completely cleans and replaces the antifreeze in a vehicle’s cooling system. To restore performance, the old coolant is drained out from the radiator and engine.
On the other hand, a drain and fill is a simpler coolant service than a flush. It involves draining the old antifreeze from the radiator and engine without flushing.
Key Differences Between Coolant Flush VS Drain and Fill
These services remove the accumulation of rust and dirt in coolant reservoirs to restore maximum engine performance. However, there are differences between them. Such as:
1. Cleaning Process
A flushing chemical solution is used in the coolant flush process. It circulates through the cooling system and dissolves and removes rust, scale, and other debris. The chemical solution is then flushed out of the system with water.
The new coolant is then added to the system. After the old coolant is drained from the radiator and replaced with new coolant, the system is then bled to remove any air pockets.
On the other hand, unlike a flush, no chemical solution or other cleaning agent is used in the cooling system in this method.
First, open the drain plug on the engine block to fully empty the system. Once drained, add replacement premixed coolant through the radiator or reservoir.
A funnel is usually used for adding the new coolant neatly. Fill until the coolant level reaches the maximum fill line.
2. Effectiveness
Drain and fill don’t tackle deposits, as no cleaning agent is introduced in this process. Scaling remains in place, which may limit circulation in the long run and develop corrosion.
Cooling performance is not fully optimized. Therefore, issues like coolant leaking from reservoirs and other problems may arise over time.
In contrast, a flush removes contaminants that impede heat transfer and corrosion protection. This fully restores the system. Thus, this service is considered more effective than drain and fill.
3. Labor and Duration
A flush is more thorough and takes 2-3 hours due to multiple clean and rinse cycles.
On the other hand, drain and fill is a basic refresh that maintains chemical levels without deep cleaning. Hence, you need only 15 to 20 minutes to complete the draining and filling process.
It means you need minimal labor and less time for the drain and fill process compared to a full flush service.
4. Ideal Vehicle Types for These Processes
High-mileage vehicles or those suffering overheating issues related to blockages are ideal for a coolant flush process. Also, it’s effective for heavily scaled fleets or commercial engines.
On the contrary, drain and fill is suitable as routine maintenance for low-mileage vehicles. But it won’t resolve temperature problems caused by internal contamination buildup over time.
5. When to Use These Services
A full coolant flush service is recommended every 2-5 years, depending on the manufacturer’s recommendations.
But you can have a drain and fill service more often than a coolant flush, such as every year. A drain and fill is also a good idea if you change the coolant type or recently bought a used car.
6. Cost
The cost of a coolant flush and a coolant drain and fill can vary depending on a few factors, like —
- Type of vehicle
- Model of the vehicle
- Location of the service shop
However, in general, a coolant flush is more expensive than a coolant drain and fill. Coolant flush costs around $70 to $150, whereas coolant drain and fill ranges between $40 to $80.
Which One Is Good for Your Coolant: Flush VS Drain and Fill?
A coolant flush is considered an ideal choice compared to the drain and fill. It’s a more comprehensive process that can eliminate old coolants as well as debris from the system.
But drain and fill are unable to remove debris, dust, and scale properly. As a result, unlike the drain and coolant, the coolant flush can do the following.
- Improve performance
- Reduce overheating
- Prevent corrosion
- Increase coolant lifespan
But if you’re tight on budget and need immediate coolant replacement, the drain and fill is a better option than the flush. It will help you to improve the engine coolant performance and reduce overheating.
Conclusion
So, what are the key differences between the coolant flush vs drain and fill? Generally, the coolant flush is for deep cleaning of the coolant components and increases the performance.
The drain and fill is a process for changing the coolant fluid only. This procedure maintains the cooling system but does not provide as deep cleaning as a full flush treatment. So, pick the one based on your needs.
Resources
- https://www.cafsti.org/wp-content/uploads/Analysis-of-Ethylene-Glycol-Based-Engine-Coolant-as-a-Vehicle-Fire-Fuel.pdf
- https://porterchester.edu/news-events/importance-proper-vehicle-maintenance
- https://www.academia.edu/36679531/A_Schematic_Design_and_an_NDT_Approach_for_a_Radiator_Tubes_Using_Nano_fluids
Leave a Reply